Blog

By Joshua A. Estes. Board Certified, Personal Injury Trial Law — Texas Board of Legal Specialization.

The short version: falling in a store is not by itself a case. Under Texas premises liability law, a store is generally responsible only if there was a condition on the property that posed an unreasonable risk of harm, the store knew about it or should have known about it, and the store failed to take reasonable care to fix it or warn about it. The hard element is almost always the middle one — notice. A spill that hit the floor thirty seconds before you did is usually nobody’s fault, no matter how badly you were hurt. That is an unsatisfying answer, and it is the honest one.

The elements, in plain English

Texas courts break a store-fall claim into parts. Roughly stated:

1. There was a condition on the property that posed an unreasonable risk of harm. A puddle, a spill, a torn mat, a broken tile, produce on the floor, a leaking cooler.
2. The store knew about the condition, or reasonably should have known about it. This is notice.
3. The store failed to exercise reasonable care to reduce or eliminate the risk — to clean it up, cone it off, or warn.
4. That failure caused the fall and the injury.

Miss any one of those and there is no claim, even with a serious injury. That is the part most people are never told.

Notice is where cases live or die

Notice comes in two forms.

Actual notice means somebody at the store knew. An employee saw the spill. A customer reported it. There is a call log, a radio call, a cleanup ticket.

Constructive notice means the condition was there long enough that a reasonably careful store should have found it. This is the fight in most cases, and it turns on time. Evidence that moves it: surveillance video showing how long the puddle sat there, sweep and inspection logs, a witness who walked past it twenty minutes earlier, or the condition of the spill itself — dried edges, cart tracks through it, footprints.

When there probably isn’t a case

An honest filter, before anyone spends months on this:

• The spill was fresh. If it happened moments before, the store had no realistic chance to find it. This is the single most common reason a real injury produces no claim.
• The hazard was open and obvious. A coned-off wet floor, a clearly marked step-down, a spill you walked around and then came back to. Texas gives property owners meaningful protection where the danger was plainly apparent.
• Nothing was actually wrong with the floor. People trip. A dry, clean, level, well-lit floor with nothing on it is not an unreasonably dangerous condition, and “I fell” is not the same as “something was wrong.”
• The injury is minor and resolved. A bruise and a sore hip that were gone in a week rarely justify a claim, and an honest lawyer will say so rather than run up a file.
• There is no proof left. No incident report, no photos, no witnesses, video already overwritten, and you told nobody at the time. The claim may have been good on day one and unprovable by day sixty.

When it starts to look like a case

• The condition had clearly been there a while — dried, tracked through, or in an area nobody had checked.
• An employee said something revealing at the scene. “I told them to get that.” “That cooler’s been leaking all week.”
• There is a recurring problem: the same leak, the same broken tile, the same entryway that floods when it rains.
• The store’s own inspection logs are missing, blank, or filled out in one sitting.
• The injury is objective and documented — a fracture, a surgery, an imaging finding — with prompt medical care.

The gift card, and the paper they hand you

Stores often move fast and pleasantly. Somebody offers to cover the ER copay, or hands over a gift card, or a claims service calls within a day or two offering a modest check to “close this out.”

Understand what that check usually comes with: a release. Signing it typically ends the claim permanently, for everyone, no matter what an X-ray finds in week three. A hairline fracture, a torn rotator cuff, or a herniated disc frequently does not identify itself on day one. The offer is not made because the store thinks the case is big.

Practical points, without drama:

• Accepting a gift card or having a copay paid is not automatically a release — but read anything you sign, and ask for a copy of it.
• If a document is put in front of you at the store or by phone that day, you are allowed to say you want to read it later.
• An “incident report” is not a release. Do make one. Ask for a copy, and if they won’t give you one, photograph it or write down the manager’s name and the report number.

What to do the day it happens

Whether or not this turns into a claim, these five things preserve the option:

1. Report it before you leave. An unreported fall is far harder to prove later.
2. Photograph the condition itself, from several angles, plus the surrounding area, any warning signs present or absent, and your shoes.
3. Get witness names and phone numbers, including any employee who spoke up.
4. Get medical care promptly, and tell the provider where and how it happened.
5. Keep the shoes and clothes you were wearing, unwashed.

Surveillance video is the one piece of evidence with a clock on it. Many systems overwrite in a matter of weeks, and once the footage is gone it is gone. If the fall was serious, the request to preserve video needs to go out early — that is one of the first things a slip and fall lawyer does, often before anything else.

Common questions

Does a store have to pay just because I fell there? No. Texas requires a condition posing an unreasonable risk, the store’s knowledge of it or reason to know, and a failure to take reasonable care. A fall alone isn’t enough.

How long does a spill have to be there? There’s no fixed number of minutes. The question is whether a reasonably careful store should have found and addressed it in the time it was there, which is why video and sweep logs matter so much.

I signed the store’s incident report. Did I hurt my claim? An incident report is normally just a record that something happened, not a release. It is worth keeping a copy so the store’s version and yours are the same document.

They offered me a gift card. Should I take it? Read anything you’re asked to sign first. If a release is attached, it typically closes the claim for good, including injuries not yet diagnosed.

What if I was partly at fault — I was on my phone? Texas applies modified comparative fault, which reduces recovery by the injured person’s share and bars it above a threshold. Being partly at fault does not automatically end a claim.

How long do I have? Injury deadlines in Texas are strict and shorter against some defendants, particularly governmental ones. Don’t calculate your own. Confirm it.

This article is general information about Texas law, not legal advice, and reading it does not create an attorney-client relationship. Deadlines in injury cases are strict and fact-specific. Talk to a lawyer about your own situation.

The Estes Law Firm, P.C. · 716 S. Union St, Richmond, Texas 77469 · (281) 238-5400 · Responsible attorney: William F. Estes.